Built Not Bought Automotive:
1,079 Crimes Against Clean Air.
A $0 Penalty.
Source: U.S. EPA Region 3 Consent Agreement & Final Order • Effective July 24, 2025
A Virginia auto shop sold illegal pollution-disabling devices on 1,079 separate occasions, the EPA confirmed it, calculated a penalty of $257,507 (enough to hire three public school teachers for a full year), and then collected exactly zero dollars.
What Built Not Bought Actually Did
Built Not Bought Automotive, LLC operates out of 628 Prosperity Way, Chesapeake, Virginia. The address is not a joke. Between January 2019 and March 2022, the EPA confirmed through its own investigation that this business sold 1,079 defeat devices. Each one was designed and sold with the specific purpose of disabling the emission control systems that the federal government requires on diesel vehicles.
These are not vague regulatory technicalities. Defeat devices are hardware or software components that shut down or circumvent systems like exhaust gas recirculation (EGR), diesel particulate filters (DPF), selective catalytic reduction (SCR), and diesel oxidation catalysts (DOC). Those systems exist for one reason: to keep poisonous gases and particles out of the air you breathe. Disabling them is not a gray area. It is a federal crime under the Clean Air Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. § 7522(a)(3)(B).
The EPA launched its investigation in February 2023, issuing a formal Request for Information. The agency physically inspected the facility on March 30, 2023. The company responded to the inquiry and, critically, the EPA’s case was built in significant part on the company’s own responses. Built Not Bought essentially documented its own violations.
The Company Knew. That’s in the Legal Record.
The EPA’s findings state explicitly that the company “knew or should have known” that these parts were being offered and installed for the purpose of defeating emission controls. This is the legal threshold required to make the sale a violation under federal law. The EPA met that threshold and documented it.
After the investigation, the EPA issued a Notice to Show Cause on September 5, 2024. Built Not Bought responded in writing on October 31, 2024, and the parties held a formal hearing on November 4, 2024. By July 24, 2025, the case was resolved — with the company paying nothing.
The Non-Financial Ledger: What Money Can’t Measure
Every one of the 1,079 defeat devices sold by Built Not Bought Automotive ended up on a diesel vehicle that then drove through someone’s neighborhood, idled near someone’s school, or rumbled past someone’s home. The emission controls those devices disabled were specifically engineered to capture nitrogen oxides (NOx), particulate matter (PM), carbon monoxide (CO), and non-methane hydrocarbons (NMHC). These are not abstract chemicals. NOx contributes directly to smog and ground-level ozone. Particulate matter penetrates deep into lung tissue. Carbon monoxide displaces oxygen in the bloodstream. These pollutants kill people over time, quietly, in ways that never make headlines.
The vehicles carrying these illegal devices were not confined to a testing facility or a closed track. They operated on public roads. They shared air with children waiting for school buses, with elderly residents sitting on front porches, with workers standing at bus stops. The Chesapeake, Virginia area, where Built Not Bought operated, is part of a broader regional airshed. Pollution released in one neighborhood does not politely stay there. It drifts. It accumulates. It becomes somebody’s asthma attack, somebody’s COPD diagnosis, somebody’s heart event.
The defeat devices disabled on-board diagnostic (OBD) systems as well. OBD systems are the internal monitors designed to alert drivers and mechanics when emission controls malfunction. By defeating these systems, the company ensured that the vehicles would pass routine inspections and that no warning light would ever tell the vehicle’s owner that their truck was pumping illegal levels of pollution into shared air. The deception was layered. The harm was invisible by design.
There is a particular cruelty in the geography of this story. Chesapeake is a working-class city. The people most likely to live near high-diesel-traffic corridors — near highways, near ports, near industrial zones — are the people with the least political power and the fewest resources to fight back. Defeat devices are not a product purchased by or for wealthy communities. The vehicles they are installed on tend to be commercial diesel trucks, work vehicles, and off-road equipment. The pollution they generate settles disproportionately on working-class and low-income neighborhoods. The company that sold those devices operated at 628 Prosperity Way. The irony of that address is brutal.
Legal Receipts: The Document Says What It Says
These are direct, verbatim statements from the EPA’s official Consent Agreement and Final Order. The agency’s own words tell this story better than any commentary.
“From at least January 2019 through March 2022, it sold 1,079 Defeat Devices that have a principal effect of bypassing, defeating, or rendering inoperative emission control systems or elements of design installed on or in EPA-certified motor vehicles or motor vehicle engines; and that it knew or should have known such parts were being offered for sale for such use.” EPA Consent Agreement, Paragraph 35 — Count I: Sale of Defeat Devices
“The EPA has determined that the appropriate civil penalty for the violations alleged herein is Two Hundred and Fifty-Seven Thousand Five Hundred and Seven Dollars ($257,507). Pursuant to the statutory requirement that the EPA consider the economic impact of the penalty on Respondent’s business, and based upon confidential business information submitted to the EPA by Respondent, including tax returns, the EPA concludes that Respondent is unable, and therefore is not required, to pay any penalty in this matter.” EPA Consent Agreement, Paragraph 39 — Civil Penalty
“Section 203(a)(3)(B) of the CAA, 42 U.S.C. § 7522(a)(3)(B), prohibits any person from manufacturing, selling, offering to sell, or installing any part or component intended for use with, or as part of, any motor vehicle or motor vehicle engine, where a principal effect of the part or component is to bypass, defeat, or render inoperative any device or element of design installed on or in a motor vehicle or motor vehicle engine in compliance with Title II of the CAA.” EPA Consent Agreement, Paragraph 26 — The Legal Prohibition Built Not Bought Violated
“Persons violating Sections 203(a)(3)(B) of the CAA, 42 U.S.C. § 7522(a)(3)(B), are subject to a civil penalty of up to $5,911 for each violation that occurred on or after November 2, 2015, where penalties are assessed on or after January 8, 2025.” EPA Consent Agreement, Paragraph 27 — The Penalty That Was Never Collected
“Respondent neither admits nor denies the specific factual allegations set forth in this Consent Agreement.” EPA Consent Agreement, Paragraph 6 — The Company’s Formal Position
The Penalty Gap: What They Owed vs. What They Paid
Who Actually Pays the Price
Public Health: The Pollution Is Still Out There
The four categories of pollutants that defeat devices are designed to unleash — NOx, particulate matter (PM), carbon monoxide (CO), and non-methane hydrocarbons (NMHC) — are each independently linked to serious health consequences. NOx generates ozone and smog. PM2.5, fine particulate matter small enough to penetrate deep lung tissue, is classified as a Group 1 carcinogen by the World Health Organization. CO reduces the blood’s capacity to carry oxygen to the brain and heart. NMHC compounds contribute to the formation of ground-level ozone, which triggers asthma attacks, reduces lung function, and inflames respiratory tissue.
The EPA document confirms that the 1,079 devices sold by Built Not Bought targeted systems including EGR (which reduces engine temperature and NOx formation), DPF (which filters particulate matter from exhaust), SCR (which chemically converts NOx into nitrogen and water), and DOC (which converts CO and NMHC into less harmful gases). Disabling all four systems simultaneously means a diesel vehicle’s exhaust goes from treated to raw. The difference in emissions output between a compliant diesel vehicle and one running with these controls defeated can be dramatic, with NOx emissions increasing by multiples.
These vehicles drove on public roads. Their exhaust entered the air at street level, at the height where people walk, where children play, where elderly residents sit outside. There is no evidence in the public record that a single health impact was tracked, measured, or compensated as part of this settlement. The company paid nothing. The communities absorbed everything.
Environmental Degradation: The Airshed Doesn’t Have a Lawyer
The Chesapeake Bay region, which includes the Chesapeake, Virginia area where Built Not Bought operated, is one of the most ecologically sensitive watersheds in the United States. NOx emissions are a primary driver of nitrogen deposition, which contributes directly to nutrient pollution in waterways. Excess nitrogen fuels algae blooms, which deplete oxygen in water and create dead zones where aquatic life cannot survive. The Chesapeake Bay has struggled for decades with exactly this type of nitrogen-driven degradation.
The Clean Air Act’s emission standards for motor vehicles, including those for NOx, PM, CO, and NMHC, exist precisely because mobile sources of air pollution are among the most difficult to regulate and among the most pervasive in their geographic reach. Every defeated emission control system on every vehicle sold by this company represents a moving, unregulated pollution source operating across an entire regional airshed. The 1,079 devices were not sold to a single facility or a single location. They dispersed across the road network, compounding the ambient pollution load across multiple communities.
The settlement resolves the civil penalty claim. It does nothing to remediate the pollution already released. It does nothing to force the recall or removal of the 1,079 devices still in the field. The EPA reserved rights to pursue further action if it determines conditions present “imminent and substantial endangerment” — but no such action is indicated in this agreement. The air absorbs the cost. The company absorbs nothing.
Economic Inequality: The Rule of Law Has a Price Floor
The legal framework here is worth reading slowly. The EPA determined the “appropriate” penalty was $257,507 (enough to pay the annual salary of roughly three registered nurses). The agency then reviewed the company’s confidential tax returns and concluded that paying even that amount would threaten the company’s ability to continue operating. So the EPA collected nothing. The company’s financial circumstances — not the scale of the harm, not the number of violations, not the environmental damage — determined the final outcome.
Compare this to what happens when an individual person cannot pay a fine. Traffic courts, municipal courts, and state enforcement agencies routinely impose payment plans, wage garnishments, license suspensions, and in some jurisdictions, incarceration for inability to pay fines far smaller than $257,507. The ordinary person who cannot pay a $500 fine faces escalating consequences. A corporation that cannot pay $257,507 for 1,079 environmental violations faces no consequences at all. The gap between those two realities is the definition of a two-tiered legal system.
The Clean Air Act’s penalty structure — up to $5,911 per violation — was designed as a deterrent. A penalty that is never collected deters nothing. Every other business in the emissions-defeat-device market now has a clear data point: sell enough devices, claim inability to pay, and walk away clean. The law exists on paper. Its enforcement depends entirely on whether the violator can afford to comply with the consequences of breaking it. For Built Not Bought Automotive, the answer was no. And the EPA accepted that answer.
The “Cost of a Life” Metric
A maximum possible penalty of $6,383,969 (enough to fund a rural community health clinic for nearly a decade, or provide a year of groceries for over 1,700 families at $300/month). The EPA collected zero percent of this amount.
Enough to pay the annual salary of three public school teachers — calculated by the EPA as the right number, then waived entirely.
Zero dollars. Zero cents. The company claimed it could not pay. The EPA accepted that claim based on confidential tax returns the public cannot see.
Each one on a vehicle. Each one on a road. Each one emitting uncontrolled NOx, particulate matter, CO, and NMHC into shared air. No recall ordered. No remediation required. No compensation to affected communities.
What Now: Who’s Watching and What You Can Do
The company’s representatives of record in this matter were Robert Manning and Gregory Munson of Gunster law firm, Tallahassee, Florida. The EPA Region 3 enforcement attorneys were Andrew Ingersoll (Assistant Regional Counsel) and Kyle Krall (Environmental Engineer). The Consent Agreement was signed by Andrea Bain, Acting Director, Enforcement and Compliance Assurance Division, EPA Region 3. The Final Order was issued by Donzetta Thomas, Regional Judicial and Presiding Officer, EPA Region 3.
Watchlist: Regulatory Bodies With Jurisdiction
- U.S. EPA Region 3: The agency that conducted this investigation and issued this settlement. They reserved the right to pursue further action if new evidence emerges that the company provided false financial information. If you have relevant information, the EPA Region 3 Enforcement tip line is publicly available.
- U.S. EPA Office of Inspector General (OIG): The OIG reviews EPA enforcement decisions and can investigate whether settlements adequately protected public health. This settlement’s $0 outcome is the kind of outcome the OIG exists to scrutinize.
- U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) Environment and Natural Resources Division: The EPA’s Final Order explicitly preserves the right to pursue criminal sanctions. DOJ retains independent authority to bring criminal charges under the Clean Air Act regardless of this civil settlement.
- Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (VDEQ): State agencies have independent authority to enforce air quality laws and may pursue additional action against this facility under Virginia environmental statutes.
- U.S. Congress: The Senate and House Environment committees have oversight authority over EPA enforcement decisions. A $0 penalty for 1,079 Clean Air Act violations is the kind of outcome that warrants a congressional inquiry into EPA enforcement adequacy.
What You Can Actually Do Right Now
Report defeat device sales in your area directly to the EPA’s Clean Air Act enforcement tip portal at epa.gov. Contact your congressional representatives and demand a hearing on EPA enforcement adequacy for defeat device cases. Support local environmental justice organizations in the Chesapeake, Virginia area and across the Hampton Roads region who are fighting for clean air in communities that bear the heaviest pollution burden. Share this story because the only accountability that does not require a company to be able to afford consequences is public pressure, and the public cannot apply pressure to cases it does not know about.
The source document for this investigation is attached below.
The consent agreement used to write this article can be found on the EPA’s website: https://yosemite.epa.gov/OA/rhc/EPAAdmin.nsf/Filings/6901FD2ED6B682D985258CD1006FBC04/$File/Built%20Not%20Bought%20Automotive%20LLC_CAA%20CAFO_July%2024%202025_Redacted.pdf
Explore by category
Product Safety Violations
When companies sell dangerous goods, consumers pay the price.
View Cases →Financial Fraud & Corruption
Lies, scams, and executive impunity that distort markets.
View Cases →Related posts:
They knew they were being investigated for pollution, but kept polluting anyway | OTR Performance
Meyer Distribution deliberately polluted our clean air to make a quick buck
White’s Diesel Performance Is The One Who Knocks On Our Clean Air
Domestic Gaskets EPA’s Emissions Case: 635 Defeat Devices Sold
