A federal appeals court ruled the former workers can take their case to a public courtroom instead of private arbitration. This is a huge W for workers rights!
TL;DR
- Who: Eight former SpaceX employees say they lost their jobs after circulating an open letter that called Elon Musk’s Twitter posts sexual harassment.
- Alleged harm: Four say they were fired the day after the letter circulated. The other four say they were fired after the company questioned them about it.
- The ruling: The Ninth Circuit held that the workers can pursue their case in court, even though they signed arbitration agreements.
Arbitration is a private process before a hired arbitrator, with no judge or jury. This ruling keeps these workers out of it, which is fantastic since private arbitration historically greatly favours the employer (which is why employers often force employees into private arbitration over open court).
The big picture
The workers say they spoke up about sexual harassment and were fired for it. SpaceX wanted the dispute moved into arbitration under contracts the workers signed at hiring. A 2022 federal law lets people who allege sexual harassment skip those agreements. The court ruled that law covers this case.
8
Former employees suing
All eight say they were fired for the open letter.
1 day
Letter to first firings
Four plaintiffs identified as authors, per the opinion.
Source: Ninth Circuit opinion, pp. 5 and 8. Figures reflect the plaintiffs’ account.
Who was harmed
- AllegedEight employees lost their jobs after drafting and circulating the letter. The opinion does not say how much pay or how many years of work each lost.
- AllegedEmployees were exposed to a workplace where sexual banter, harassment, and gender discrimination were “commonplace,” the plaintiffs say. They say Musk’s sexually explicit posts, and some that demeaned women and LGBTQ people, were shared among staff.
- DocumentedThe plaintiffs now stay out of arbitration, a ruling that affects where and how their claims are heard.
“The day after Plaintiffs circulated the letter, SpaceX terminated four Plaintiffs who were identified as authors.”
Ninth Circuit opinion, p. 8, in the section describing the Complaint. Status: alleged.
What they say SpaceX did
- The remaining four plaintiffs were investigated by human resources over the letter. Each admitted helping draft it, then was fired “soon after,” the opinion says.
- The workers sued over retaliation, harassment, and discrimination, among other claims. Retaliation is the only claim all eight share.
“conceiving, writing, and distributing the Open Letter.”
SpaceX’s stated reason for the firings, as recounted in the Ninth Circuit opinion, p. 9. Status: alleged.
How it unfolded
- Before the letterNational news outlets report on sexual harassment allegations at SpaceX. The plaintiffs write an open letter to management.
- The next daySpaceX fires four plaintiffs identified as authors.
- Following weeksHR investigates the other four. They admit helping draft the letter and are fired.
- Nov. 10, 2026The Ninth Circuit affirms the order keeping the case in court.
Source: Ninth Circuit opinion, pp. 8 to 9 and 1 to 2. Events before the ruling are the plaintiffs’ account. Sequence does not prove cause.
What the court ruled
“Congress enacted the EFAA specifically to override that preference and to permit sexual misconduct claims to proceed in court.”
Ninth Circuit opinion, p. 27 (majority, Judge Friedland). Status: ruled. “Preference” refers to companies preferring arbitration.
| Question | SpaceX argued | Court majority held |
|---|---|---|
| What must workers show? | Allegations strong enough to survive a motion to dismiss. | A claim that the conduct is sexual harassment is enough to invoke the law. |
| Does retaliation count? | No, it is not itself harassment. | Yes, retaliation for opposing alleged harassment qualifies. |
| Which claims stay in court? | Unrelated claims should go to arbitration. | The “entire case” stays in court. |
Source: Ninth Circuit opinion, pp. 10 to 30. Table compares legal arguments, not findings about the facts.
- Their response: SpaceX argued the workers could not meet the standard for a harassment claim, and that the claim should be tested before leaving arbitration.
“cannot plead plausible claims for hostile work environment sexual harassment.”
SpaceX’s argument that the plaintiffs belonged in arbitration, as quoted in the Ninth Circuit opinion, p. 26. Status: denied (the company disputes that the posts amount to harassment).
- The dissent: Judge Tung would have sent the case back for a stricter test, warning that workers could escape arbitration by simply saying a dispute involves sexual harassment.
This article is based solely on the Ninth Circuit’s published opinion in Holland-Thielen v. SpaceX (No. 25-4811, filed Nov. 10, 2026), including the dissent. It does not include the underlying complaint, SpaceX’s filings, or any company statement, so all descriptions of what happened to the workers are the plaintiffs’ allegations as summarized by the court.
Explore by category
Antitrust
Monopolies and anti-competition tactics used to crush rivals.
View Cases →Product Safety Violations
When companies sell dangerous goods, consumers pay the price.
View Cases →Environmental Violations
Pollution, ecological collapse, and unchecked greed.
View Cases →Labor Exploitation
Wage theft, worker abuse, and unsafe conditions.
View Cases →Data Breaches & Privacy
Misuse and mishandling of personal information.
View Cases →Financial Fraud & Corruption
Lies, scams, and executive impunity that distort markets.
View Cases →Intellectual Property
IP theft that punishes originality and rewards copying.
View Cases →Misleading Marketing
False claims that waste money and bury critical safety info.
View Cases →


