A systemic practice designed to shift routine maintenance costs onto tenants was recently struck down by Massachusetts’ highest court
In a ruling with sweeping implications for renters (that I’ll go over in a little bit), the Supreme Judicial Court found that lease provisions used by JRK Property Holdings, Inc. which require tenants to pay for professional cleaning or forfeit parts of their security deposit for standard upkeep like painting and carpet cleaning, directly violate state law.
This decision exposes a contractual mechanism which leveraged the “inferior bargaining positions” of the housing tenants to extract funds. Funds that were used to pay for what the law defines as a landlord’s responsibility: the cost of reasonable wear and tear of somebody living in the living units.
Anatomy of the Scheme
So what exactly happened here?
- The Mandate: JRK Property Holdings required tenants to sign a lease addendum titled “Move Out Cleaning & Replacement Charges”. This addendum mandated that “Resident is required to have the apartment professionally cleaned and carpet cleaned upon move out”.
- The Penalty: If tenants failed to hire professional cleaners, the addendum stipulated that a fixed menu of charges for painting, cleaning, and other repairs “will be applied”. These charges covered items ranging from “touch-up paint” and “carpet cleaning” to resurfacing a bathtub or replacing an exterior door.
- The Loophole Ignored: The charges were to be “assessed regardless of how long [a] resident occupies the apartment,” a direct contradiction to the concept of natural deterioration over time.
- The Illegality: Massachusetts law, G. L. c. 186, § 15B, explicitly forbids landlords from using a security deposit to cover “reasonable wear and tear”. This refers to the gradual deterioration of a property from a tenant making normal, reasonable use of it as a home.
- The Verdict: The Supreme Judicial Court declared that because the lease provision imposes charges for repairs that may be the result of reasonable wear and tear, it conflicts with state law. As a result, the provision is “against public policy and therefore void and unenforceable”.
The Consequences
This ruling in the Mass. exposes some important shit about our modern day late-stage capitalistic society that I want to yap about for a little bit:
The Economic Fallout
The primary effect is a direct, unlawful transfer of wealth from tenants to landlords. By recasting routine business expenses (such as repainting an apartment after a long-term tenancy or cleaning carpets showing years of use) as tenant-incurred “damages,” property management firms can inflate their profits at the direct expense of renters
Massachewsett’s security deposit law was specifically designed to protect tenants, for whom the “legal expense of chasing a security deposit would be more than the amount of the deposit” itself. This practice institutionalizes the exploitation of that power imbalance.
The Erosion of Trust
When a landlord inserts void and unenforceable clauses into a lease, it undermines the integrity of the contract itself.
Tenants sign these agreements believing them to be legally binding, unaware that they are waiving rights the Legislature has explicitly protected.
This practice understandably fosters a climate of distrust and cynicism, transforming the lease from a document of mutual agreement into a tool of potential deception. The court’s opinion reinforces that the law was created as an “elaborate scheme of rights and duties to prevent abuses and to insure fairness to the tenant” …. a scheme this lease provision attempted to dismantle.
You can read about the settlement from this case by visiting: https://jrksettlement.com/
💡 Explore Corporate Misconduct by Category
Corporations harm people every day — from wage theft to pollution. Learn more by exploring key areas of injustice.
- 💀 Product Safety Violations — When companies risk lives for profit.
- 🌿 Environmental Violations — Pollution, ecological collapse, and unchecked greed.
- 💼 Labor Exploitation — Wage theft, worker abuse, and unsafe conditions.
- 🛡️ Data Breaches & Privacy Abuses — Misuse and mishandling of personal information.
- 💵 Financial Fraud & Corruption — Lies, scams, and executive impunity.
