πŸ³οΈβ€βš§οΈ trans rights are human rights πŸ³οΈβ€βš§οΈ
Theme
◀
▶

Inside EPA’s Five Safety Allegations at a Terminal Handling More Than 80 Million Pounds of Butane

Environment | EPA enforcement

Inside EPA’s Five Safety Allegations at a Terminal Handling More Than 80 Million Pounds of Butane

Federal inspectors cited damaged pressure gauges, illegible emergency controls, missing vehicle barriers and other alleged failures at NGL Supply Terminal Company’s Chesapeake facility. The company settled without admitting or denying the specific factual allegations.

Facility: Chesapeake Export TerminalDocket: CAA-03-2026-0281Filed: Aug. 31, 2026

What the order says

  • EPA alleged five violations of federal Risk Management Program requirements at the Chesapeake, Virginia terminal.
  • The agency said the facility was handling more than 80 million pounds of butane and 150,000 pounds of propane during the violation period.
  • The cited conditions included damaged gauges, unreadable emergency shutdown signage, inadequate tank labels and process equipment without vehicle-impact protection.
  • Most alleged violations continued from at least Aug. 20, 2025 through June 12, 2026. The tank-growth allegation continued through June 16.
  • NGL Supply Terminal Company agreed to a $6,300 civil penalty and certified that the alleged violations had been corrected.
  • The company admitted EPA’s jurisdiction but neither admitted nor denied the specific factual allegations.

The order documents preventive safeguards that EPA said were missing at a facility storing regulated substances far above federal threshold quantities.

At a terminal holding an inventory measured in tens of millions of pounds, EPA inspectors focused on safeguards that can look mundane until something goes wrong: a readable shutdown sign, an intact pressure gauge, a barrier between heavy machinery and process equipment, and labels that tell people what is inside a tank.

The Aug. 31, 2026 final order ratified a settlement between EPA Region 3 and NGL Supply Terminal Company LLC over conditions at the Chesapeake Export Terminal on South Military Highway. EPA said its inspection and follow-up investigation identified five Risk Management Program violations. The company agreed to pay the penalty, waive a hearing and appeal, and comply with the agreement.

80M+Pounds of butane EPA said the facility handled
150,000Pounds of propane EPA said the facility handled
5Risk-management violations alleged by EPA
$6,300Civil penalty required by the settlement

The safeguards EPA said were missing

Federal Risk Management Program rules apply when regulated substances are present above specified thresholds. The settlement identifies a threshold of 10,000 pounds for both butane and propane and says the terminal had more than that amount in a covered process.

Some allegations involved mechanical integrity. Others involved recognized and generally accepted good engineering practices, a regulatory concept that requires equipment and operations to follow established engineering and safety standards.

  1. 1

    Biological growth on tanks and foundations

    EPA alleged that NGL failed to remove biological growth from tanks ST-1 and ST-2 and their foundations.

    Alleged through June 16, 2026
  2. 2

    No adequate vehicle-impact protection

    Process equipment in areas accessible to vehicles allegedly lacked bollards, guardrails or another acceptable form of protection from heavy machinery.

    Alleged through June 12, 2026
  3. 3

    Damaged pressure gauges

    EPA said pressure gauges on the compressor and pump skid had been observed damaged and were not replaced during the alleged violation period.

    Alleged through June 12, 2026
  4. 4

    Illegible emergency shutdown signage

    The agency alleged that emergency shutdown signage was faded and unreadable, despite standards requiring shutoff controls to be visible, accessible and identified.

    Alleged through June 12, 2026
  5. 5

    Inadequate tank labels

    EPA alleged that signs on tanks ST-1, ST-5 and ST-10 did not adequately identify their contents for emergency response purposes.

    Alleged through June 12, 2026

Why these details matter at a fuel terminal

The settlement does not report a release, fire, injury or other accident. It also does not conclude that any cited condition caused harm. The standards at issue are preventive: they are intended to reduce the chance that equipment damage, a confusing control or a missing label will complicate an abnormal event.

Prevent contact

Bollards and guardrails separate vehicles and heavy machinery from process equipment that could be damaged by an impact.

Detect and control

Usable gauges give operators pressure information, while clear shutdown markings help identify emergency controls quickly.

Identify the hazard

Tank labels tell workers and emergency responders what material is present. That information can shape decisions during an incident.

Biological growth presents a different maintenance issue. EPA cited its removal under mechanical-integrity requirements, which govern the inspection and maintenance of process equipment. The agreement does not describe the extent of the growth or document that it had damaged the tanks or foundations.

The respondent β€œneither admits nor denies the specific factual allegations” in the agreement.EPA expedited settlement agreement, paragraph 11

Nearly ten months from inspection to correction

EPA dated each alleged violation from at least the day of its inspection. The agreement records June 2026 end dates, followed by signatures and a final order in August.

Aug. 20, 2025

An authorized EPA representative inspected the Chesapeake Export Terminal for compliance with Clean Air Act risk-management requirements.

June 12, 2026

The alleged violation periods ended for vehicle-impact protection, damaged gauges, emergency shutdown signage and tank labeling.

June 16, 2026

The alleged violation period concerning biological growth on tanks ST-1 and ST-2 and their foundations ended.

Aug. 31, 2026

EPA filed the final order, making the settlement effective and ordering NGL to comply with its terms.

The price of resolving the case

The civil penalty was $6,300, payable within 30 days of the agreement’s effective date. NGL separately certified that it spent $11,830.89 correcting the alleged violations and coming into compliance.

EPA said it considered the statutory penalty factors in Section 113(e)(1) of the Clean Air Act, but the agreement does not provide a line-by-line calculation. That leaves readers unable to determine how much weight the agency assigned to the chemical quantities, the duration of each allegation, the company’s compliance spending or other statutory considerations.

$11,830.89Compliance spending certified by the company
30 daysTime allowed to pay the $6,300 penalty
0Specific factual allegations admitted by the company
1 final orderBinding order incorporating the settlement

What NGL accepted without admitting the allegations

NGL admitted the agreement’s jurisdictional allegations, consented to the final order, waived its right to a hearing and appeal, and agreed not to contest EPA’s jurisdiction over the agreement. It did not admit the specific factual allegations.

The company’s most consequential affirmative statement was its compliance certification. By signing, its representative certified, subject to civil and criminal penalties for a false submission to the federal government, that the alleged violations had been corrected and that information supplied to EPA was true and accurate.

The supplied order contains no separate company explanation of how the cited conditions developed, how they were discovered internally, or what lasting changes were made beyond correcting the individual items.

The scale makes ordinary safeguards consequential

This is not a record of a catastrophic accident. It is a record of federal inspectors alleging that basic preventive measures were not in place at a terminal handling more than 80 million pounds of butane and 150,000 pounds of propane.

The settlement’s limits matter. NGL did not admit the factual allegations, and the document identifies no injury or release. Yet the final order also records a binding resolution: the company paid to correct the cited conditions, certified that the work was complete, accepted a civil penalty and gave up its right to contest the matter.

The central lesson is less dramatic than an explosion and more useful before one occurs. At facilities built around large inventories of regulated substances, maintenance, labels, readable controls and physical barriers are not peripheral details. They are the layers intended to stop a manageable problem from becoming an emergency.

Source: U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Region 3, Expedited Settlement Agreement and Final Order, docket CAA-03-2026-0281, filed Aug. 31, 2026. The document records EPA’s allegations and the settlement terms. It does not include a contested factual ruling, a separate inspection report or documentation of an accident or injury.
Aleeia
Aleeia

I'm Aleeia, the creator of this website.

I have 6+ years of experience as an independent researcher covering corporate misconduct, sourced from legal documents, regulatory filings, and professional legal databases.

My background includes a Supply Chain Management degree from Michigan State University's Eli Broad College of Business, and years working inside the industries I now cover.

Every post on this site was either written or personally reviewed and edited by me before publication.

Learn more about my research standards and editorial process by visiting my About page

Articles: 2400