โš ๏ธ
Core Allegations
What the company did ยท 6 points
โ–พ
01 Live It Up Super Greens (both Original and Wild Berry flavors) were contaminated with Salmonella, a dangerous bacterial pathogen capable of causing severe illness, hospitalization, and death. high
02 Defendant marketed and advertised the products as containing “the highest quality ingredients,” “all the good stuff,” and “none of the bad stuff” while those products harbored a pathogen that caused documented hospitalization. high
03 Defendant claimed to use “good manufacturing practices,” a representation the complaint alleges is false given the Salmonella contamination that resulted from inadequate sourcing, testing, or inspection procedures. high
04 Defendant knew or should have known about Salmonella contamination from its own testing and expertise and from third-party testing, yet failed to timely disclose or remove the recalled products from the market. high
05 The products were sold nationally, including in Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Virgin Islands, through the company’s direct-to-consumer website since September 2024 and on Amazon.com since July 30, 2025, with expiration dates running as late as January 2028. high
06 Consumers purchased the products through a monthly subscription model, meaning repeated exposure and repeated payment for products that were unfit for human consumption at the time of each delivery. medium
โ˜ฃ๏ธ
Public Health and Safety
Unsafe products and documented harm ยท 6 points
โ–พ
01 Salmonella can cause serious and sometimes fatal infections, particularly in young children, elderly persons, and those with weakened immune systems. The FDA has documented this risk explicitly. high
02 Healthy persons infected with Salmonella experience fever, bloody diarrhea, nausea, vomiting, and severe abdominal pain. In rare but documented cases, the bacteria enter the bloodstream and cause arterial infections, endocarditis, and arthritis. high
03 The CDC estimates Salmonella causes approximately 1.35 million illnesses, 26,500 hospitalizations, and 420 deaths in the United States each year. It is the leading cause of hospitalizations and deaths from food poisoning in the country. high
04 As of the filing date, 45 illnesses and 12 hospitalizations across the United States were possibly linked to Live It Up’s recalled products. Lead plaintiff Charlyn Adkins was transported by ambulance to an emergency room in December 2025 with severe stomach cramps consistent with Salmonella poisoning. high
05 Plaintiff Adkins incurred thousands of dollars in medical bills as a direct result of consuming the recalled product. Other class members similarly suffered severe pain and discomfort alongside significant medical expenses. high
06 Dietary supplement manufacturers are required under industry standards to implement quality and preventive control practices to stop Salmonella contamination before products reach consumers. The defendant’s products indicate these measures were absent or failed. medium
๐Ÿ’ฐ
Profit Over People
Revenue prioritized over consumer safety ยท 5 points
โ–พ
01 Defendant used emotionally resonant wellness marketing, including the promise of “better digestion,” “less bloating,” “healthy aging,” “immune support,” and “enhanced energy,” to command premium prices for products it failed to make safe. high
02 The complaint alleges that defendant failed to timely recall products even after becoming aware of Salmonella contamination, allowing continued sales of unsafe products and continued collection of subscription revenue. high
03 The lawsuit argues defendant was unjustly enriched because it retained payment from consumers for products that were worthless and unsafe, products no reasonable consumer would have purchased if the contamination had been disclosed. high
04 The monthly subscription model kept consumers locked into repeated purchases and repeated exposure, generating recurring revenue even as the company allegedly knew its products carried contamination risk. medium
05 Plaintiffs seek punitive damages, citing the allegation that the defendant’s concealment of the contamination and its failure to act was willful, wanton, and undertaken with reckless disregard for consumer safety. medium
โš–๏ธ
Corporate Accountability Failures
Concealment, delay, and inadequate testing ยท 5 points
โ–พ
01 Defendant had exclusive access to its own test results and manufacturing data showing dangerous levels of Salmonella contamination, yet did not disclose that information to consumers before they purchased and consumed the products. high
02 Nowhere on the recalled product packaging did the company disclose any risk of Salmonella contamination. Instead, it displayed health claims and a list of nutritious-sounding ingredients while suppressing the truth about safety. high
03 The complaint alleges fraudulent concealment: the defendant intentionally omitted contamination information to induce purchases it would not otherwise have made, constituting fraud by omission under the law. high
04 The FDA recall was announced on January 15, 2026, and FDA published the recall notice around January 20, 2026. The gap between when the defendant knew of contamination and when the recall occurred is a key contested issue in the litigation. medium
05 The defendant’s violations of New York General Business Law sections 349 and 350 (deceptive acts and false advertising) reflect conduct that regulators and courts treat as an injury to the public, not merely a private dispute between buyer and seller. medium
๐Ÿ›๏ธ
Regulatory Failures
How oversight broke down ยท 4 points
โ–พ
01 Dietary supplements are subject to FDA oversight and manufacturers are required to follow Good Manufacturing Practices (GMPs). The contamination of Live It Up Super Greens suggests these practices either were not followed or were not enforced in time to prevent harm. high
02 Products with expiration dates extending to January 2028 were part of the recall, meaning contaminated products could have remained in consumers’ homes for years without being identified as recalled. medium
03 The complaint notes potential unauthorized third-party distribution through eBay, Walmart.com, and other platforms, suggesting the company’s supply chain lacked the oversight controls necessary to contain or trace contaminated product movement. medium
04 The FDA’s response, publishing recall notices approximately five days after the company’s announcement, illustrates the reactive nature of supplement industry regulation: contaminated products reach consumers first, and the safety net arrives after the harm is done. medium