About 350 delivery drivers were allotted roughly $2,800 each, while 230 drivers in a parallel case settled for $71,739 each. An appeals court said the other drivers’ lawyers moved too late to step in.
TL;DR
- Documented: Apria’s settlement with one set of plaintiffs totals $5,750,000. Of that, $977,500 was earmarked for an estimated 350 delivery drivers, or about $2,793 each by our arithmetic.
- Documented: A separate case by 230 delivery drivers settled for $16.5 million, or $71,739 each before fees and costs.
- Alleged: Lawyers for drivers in another case say the cheaper deal was a “reverse auction,” where a company settles with weaker lawyers to block bigger claims.
- Ruled: The court did not decide whether that happened. It held the drivers’ bid to intervene was untimely.
- Human impact: Drivers inside the cheaper deal were allotted a small fraction of what drivers in the other case received.
Same company, same kind of claim, a gap of roughly $69,000 per driver. Nice.
The big picture
Apria Healthcare delivers home medical equipment, often through drivers hired by staffing agencies. Drivers sued over wages in two tracks. One group fought for years and was weeks from trial. Another case, started by a different set of plaintiffs, settled for far less per driver.
$71,739
Per driver, Quintero case
Before fees and costs. 230 class members, $16.5 million total.
$977,500
Earmarked, Smith case drivers
For an estimated 350 drivers. About $2,793 each (calculated).
Source: Court of Appeal opinion, pp. 2 to 3 and 6. Smith figure is $977,500 divided by 350, our calculation. Quintero figure is before fees and costs; the source does not say whether the Smith figure is.
Who was harmed
- Documented Drivers in the Smith case were allotted $977,500 as a group, a fraction of the Quintero per-person amount.
- Alleged Lawyers for drivers in a third case say the Smith deal would “wipe out claims of the Couriers.” Courier means delivery driver.
- Possible Drivers who stayed in the Smith class may have given up claims worth more. The opinion does not measure that.
“The Quintero action ultimately settled for $16.5 million for 230 class members, or $71,739 for each class member before fees and costs.”
Court of Appeal opinion, Part I.G, p. 6. Status: found (the court’s account of the record).
“The Smith plaintiffs and Apria agreed to settle the Smith action for $5,750,000, of which $977,500 was earmarked for an estimated class of 350 delivery drivers.”
Court of Appeal opinion, Part I, p. 3. Status: found (the court’s account of the record).
What the record shows
- Apria’s lawyers told a court the Smith deal was a “settlement in principle” affecting the other case, yet kept its terms secret.
- That court denied Apria’s request to pause the other case, citing Apria’s refusal to disclose the terms.
- Drivers’ lawyers raised “reverse auction” concerns in emails and letters starting in August 2024, per the opinion.
“settlement in principle that will directly impact the PAGA claims at issue in the Tisdale case.”
Apria’s reply brief, quoted in Court of Appeal opinion, Part I.H, p. 7. Status: admitted. PAGA is a California law letting workers seek penalties for labor violations.
“Were a stay to be granted without protecting the putative class from the collusion of a reverse auction, the putative class would suffer great harm.”
Tisdale and Pratt opposition brief, Oct. 15, 2024, quoted in Court of Appeal opinion, Part I.H, p. 7. Status: alleged.
Timeline
- Feb. 1, 2024Quintero drivers win a ruling against one of Apria’s defenses; trial set for Nov. 4, 2024.
- June 10, 2024Smith plaintiffs and Apria accept a mediator’s proposal.
- Sept. 2024Quintero case settles for $16.5 million.
- Oct. 15, 2024Tisdale and Pratt tell a court they have “grave concerns.”
- May 8, 2025They ask to intervene in the Smith case.
- Aug. 25, 2025Smith settlement receives final approval.
Source: Court of Appeal opinion. Sequence does not by itself show cause.
Their response
Apria and the Smith plaintiffs opposed intervention. They argued it was untimely and unwarranted. The opinion does not record Apria directly denying collusion.
“Even assuming the Smith settlement was inadequate, we conclude the application was untimely.”
Court of Appeal opinion, Part II.D, p. 27. Status: ruled.
What we don’t know
- Whether the Smith settlement was collusive. The court did not decide.
- How the other $4,772,500 is divided, or whether the $977,500 is before fees.
- How strong the two cases were. Quintero was near trial after a ruling for the drivers.
- Whether any Smith class members lost claims. A separate appeal by a class member, Ahsaki Hudson, is pending; the court expressed no opinion on it.
Sources: This article is based solely on the California Court of Appeal’s published opinion in Smith v. Apria Healthcare (Case No. C104113, Third Appellate District). It reports the court’s account of the record, not the underlying filings, and the opinion does not say how the Smith settlement was ultimately distributed to each driver.
Explore by category
Antitrust
Monopolies and anti-competition tactics used to crush rivals.
View Cases →Product Safety Violations
When companies sell dangerous goods, consumers pay the price.
View Cases →Environmental Violations
Pollution, ecological collapse, and unchecked greed.
View Cases →Labor Exploitation
Wage theft, worker abuse, and unsafe conditions.
View Cases →Data Breaches & Privacy
Misuse and mishandling of personal information.
View Cases →Financial Fraud & Corruption
Lies, scams, and executive impunity that distort markets.
View Cases →Intellectual Property
IP theft that punishes originality and rewards copying.
View Cases →Misleading Marketing
False claims that waste money and bury critical safety info.
View Cases →


