Environmental enforcement
Unlabeled Containers and an Outdated Emergency Plan: EPAβs McClarin Case
A 2022 inspection led EPA to allege hazardous waste failures across a McClarin Composites plant in Wapato, Washington. The company settled for $40,000, certified that it had corrected the alleged violations, and neither admitted nor denied the specific factual allegations.
The case in brief
- EPA said a November 2022 inspection identified hazardous waste management problems involving waste determinations, labels, open containers, training, emergency planning, manifests and aerosol cans.
- A follow-up inventory covered 185 containers of customer and company waste. Safety data sheets indicated that certain materials could be ignitable, corrosive or both after becoming waste.
- Inspectors allegedly found 35 containers without accumulation start dates and saw waste acetone sprayed onto a floor and backdrop instead of into a container.
- The facilityβs contingency plan allegedly lacked a complete evacuation plan, current emergency contacts, equipment details, maps and a required quick reference guide.
- McClarin agreed to pay $40,000. EPA said it reduced the penalty after the company submitted information supporting a claim that a higher amount would prevent it from continuing in business.
- McClarin neither admitted nor denied the specific factual allegations. Its representative certified that the alleged violations had been corrected by the date of signing.
The record describes a control system that allegedly failed at several levels, from identifying waste to preparing for an emergency.
The inspection captured more than a paperwork lapse
At the Heavy Truck Detail Area, EPA inspectors said they watched facility personnel clean a paint spray gun by directing waste acetone onto the floor and the backdrop behind a hazardous waste container. The acetone was supposed to enter the container.
That observation became one part of a much broader Resource Conservation and Recovery Act case. According to the consent agreement, McClarin operated a fiberglass and plastic components plant at 180 East Jones Road in Wapato, within the boundaries of the Yakama Reservation. EPA classified the plant as a large quantity generator of hazardous waste, but not as a permitted hazardous waste treatment, storage or disposal facility.
Large quantity generators can accumulate hazardous waste without a storage permit only if they satisfy detailed conditions. Those rules govern basic controls such as identifying waste, closing and labeling containers, tracking how long waste has accumulated, training personnel and preparing for fires or releases.
EPAβs case was not simply that a label or signature was missing. The agency alleged that McClarin failed to meet conditions that allow a large quantity generator to accumulate hazardous waste without obtaining a treatment, storage or disposal permit.
EPA traced failures from identification to emergency response
The consent agreement organizes the case into separate regulatory counts. Read together, they describe alleged weaknesses at three points in the waste management chain.
Identify and track
- No timely hazardous waste determination for certain discarded materials
- Missing hazard labels and accumulation dates
- Eleven manifests without the required individual signature
Contain and separate
- Open containers in five areas
- Waste acetone directed outside a container
- Ignitable and corrosive waste allegedly stored together
Prepare and respond
- Incomplete training records
- A missed weekly inspection
- An outdated and incomplete contingency plan
Waste first had to be identified
Inspectors found expired and discarded material in the plantβs central accumulation area. An inventory provided during the inspection documented 118 customer-waste containers holding 1,059 pounds of paint waste, excluding other waste. A later inventory covering customer waste and McClarinβs own containers identified 185 containers in total.
Safety data sheets for certain materials indicated that they could exhibit ignitability, corrosivity or both if and when they became waste. EPA alleged that McClarin had not completed the required hazardous waste determination for the relevant material by November 29, 2022.
Containers were allegedly open, undated or improperly marked
The agreement says hazardous waste containers lacked the words βHazardous Waste,β an indication of the contentsβ hazards, or both across seven substantially different locations. Its itemized list contains six location entries. EPA also alleged that containers were left open in five areas and that 35 containers had no visible accumulation start date.
Those dates determine whether a large quantity generator remains within the ordinary 90-day accumulation limit. Hazard labels tell workers and responders what they may be handling. Closed containers limit opportunities for waste or vapors to escape. The agreement does not report that the labeling and closure failures caused a documented injury.
Some incompatible wastes allegedly shared a pallet
Near the customer waste, inspectors said they found corrosive waste coded D002 and ignitable waste coded D001 stored together on at least one pallet. Federal rules require incompatible materials stored nearby to be separated or protected by a dike, berm, wall or similar device.
EPA also alleged that an aerosol-can puncturing device in the Wheel Detail Area lacked a filter, despite the facilityβs own operating procedure stating that the device must discharge aerosol into a filtered container.
The emergency plan described a facility that no longer existed
EPA reviewed a hazardous waste contingency plan dated January 12, 2021. The document listed three emergency coordinators, but the primary and secondary contacts were no longer employed at the plant. It identified spill kits, extinguishers, radios and phones without giving the specific locations or capabilities of the equipment.
The plan also allegedly lacked an evacuation plan, evacuation signals, a description of alarm systems and specific procedures for explosions. EPA said the required quick reference guide was missing, along with maps showing hazardous waste locations, access routes, the facilityβs surroundings and water supplies.
Inspectors were also told that the facility no longer generated three waste streams still named in the plan. The list had not been brought up to date.
| Required control | EPAβs allegation | Practical function |
|---|---|---|
| Current coordinators | Primary and secondary contacts no longer worked at the facility. | Identifies who has authority during an emergency. |
| Equipment details | Specific locations and capabilities were not listed. | Helps workers and responders find usable equipment quickly. |
| Evacuation procedures | Signals, routes and alarm details were incomplete or absent. | Provides instructions when fire or a release may block normal routes. |
| Quick reference guide | Maps, waste locations, access routes and water-supply information were missing. | Gives outside responders a concise view of site hazards and access. |
McClarin updated the plan on February 28, 2024, correcting several deficiencies. The agreement says a second update on March 25, 2026, corrected the remaining items identified by EPA.
Records pointed to gaps in training, inspection and shipment certification
EPA said McClarin could not produce two years of annual review records for the person designated to manage hazardous waste. It also lacked training records for another hazardous waste manager.
Inspectors reviewed three years of weekly inspection records and found one missing inspection, covering August 28 through September 3, 2022. Weekly inspections are intended to detect leaking or deteriorating containers in a central accumulation area.
EPA also reviewed hazardous waste manifests from November 2019 through November 2022. On 11 manifests, the certification block contained βMcClarin Plasticsβ or βMcClarin Compositesβ rather than the name and signature of a specific authorized representative. A manifest is the tracking record that follows hazardous waste sent off site for treatment, storage or disposal.
The agreement does not say the manifest errors caused waste to be lost, misdelivered or improperly disposed of. It alleges that the required certifications were not completed correctly.
The risks were concrete, but documented harm is limited
The rules at issue protect workers, emergency responders and the surrounding environment from preventable uncertainty. Labels identify hazards. Closed containers help contain waste and vapors. Separation prevents incompatible materials from interacting. A current emergency plan tells people whom to call, where equipment is located and how to evacuate.
The source documents one direct handling incident: inspectors allegedly observed waste acetone sprayed onto the floor and backdrop. It also describes an aerosol puncturing device without a filter. The agreement does not quantify material released in either situation.
It does not report a fire, explosion, worker injury, medical event, off-site release or measured contamination. It also does not establish a specific impact on Yakama Nation members or other nearby residents. Those absences matter. The case supports a finding that safeguards were allegedly missing, not a claim that every potential consequence occurred.
Nearly four years passed from inspection to final order
- McClarinβs hazardous waste contingency plan was dated. EPA later alleged that it was incomplete and outdated.
- EPA conducted its RCRA compliance evaluation inspection at the Wapato plant.
- McClarin updated the contingency plan and corrected several of the deficiencies described by EPA.
- The company updated the plan again. The agreement says this corrected the remaining cited plan deficiencies.
- McClarin and EPA signed the consent agreement. A company representative certified that the alleged violations had been corrected.
- EPAβs regional judicial officer issued the final order ratifying the settlement terms.
The settlement closed the penalty case without proving the allegations
McClarin agreed to pay a $40,000 civil penalty within 30 days of the final orderβs effective date. EPA said it reduced the penalty based on information submitted by the company to support its claim that it could not pay a higher penalty and continue in business.
The agreement does not disclose the unreduced penalty EPA considered. It notes that RCRA authorized penalties of up to $121,275 per day of noncompliance for each violation, but that statutory ceiling is not a calculation of what McClarin would have owed in this case.
“Respondent neither admits nor denies the specific factual allegations contained in this Consent Agreement.”EPA consent agreement, paragraph 4.2
McClarin admitted EPAβs jurisdiction, waived its right to contest the allegations in this proceeding and waived an appeal of the final order. Its representative also certified that the alleged violations had been corrected as of the signing date.
The final order settles EPAβs civil-penalty claims for the alleged violations. It does not remove McClarinβs continuing obligation to comply with RCRA, and it does not waive the governmentβs ability to pursue other relief or criminal sanctions for violations of law.
Correction is not the same as a public accounting
The record says the contingency plan was updated and all alleged violations were corrected. It does not provide a detailed public account of every operational change, such as revised inspection systems, new training controls, container-management procedures or independent verification after the 2022 inspection.
The central lesson is not that every clerical defect produced a disaster. It is that hazardous waste protection depends on ordinary controls working together. At McClarinβs plant, EPA alleged that identification, containment, tracking and emergency preparation all broke down at once. The settlement records correction and a penalty, but leaves the public with limited information about how durable those corrections will be.
Explore by category
Antitrust
Monopolies and anti-competition tactics used to crush rivals.
View Cases →Product Safety Violations
When companies sell dangerous goods, consumers pay the price.
View Cases →Environmental Violations
Pollution, ecological collapse, and unchecked greed.
View Cases →Labor Exploitation
Wage theft, worker abuse, and unsafe conditions.
View Cases →Data Breaches & Privacy
Misuse and mishandling of personal information.
View Cases →Financial Fraud & Corruption
Lies, scams, and executive impunity that distort markets.
View Cases →Intellectual Property
IP theft that punishes originality and rewards copying.
View Cases →Misleading Marketing
False claims that waste money and bury critical safety info.
View Cases →


