What the order establishes
- EPA identified two violations involving underground fuel-tank compliance at Colonial Shell, 4101 Randolph Road in Wheaton, Maryland.
- The agency said annual testing of automatic line leak detectors was not completed from at least April 20 through September 11, 2024.
- EPA also said Montgomery Petro did not comply with financial responsibility requirements from at least December 15, 2023 through September 15, 2024.
- The facility had three tanks with a combined capacity of 30,000 gallons for regular gasoline, premium gasoline, and diesel.
- Montgomery Petro accepted a $4,446 penalty and certified that the alleged violations had been corrected.
- The company admitted EPA’s jurisdiction but neither admitted nor denied the specific factual allegations.
The record concerns missing compliance safeguards. It does not document that fuel leaked from any tank.
The core findingThirty thousand gallons of capacity, two required protections out of compliance
Under a Wheaton service station sat three underground tanks with capacity for 30,000 gallons of fuel. According to EPA, two separate layers of regulatory compliance had lapsed: required annual testing of automatic line leak detectors and compliance with financial responsibility rules.
Those are different obligations. Leak-detector testing concerns whether required detection equipment has received its annual test. Financial responsibility concerns the operator’s compliance with rules requiring financial capacity for underground storage-tank obligations. The settlement says Montgomery Petro failed both requirements during specified periods, but it does not explain the exact financial instrument, document, or amount that was deficient.
The distinction matters. A missed detector test is not proof of a leak, just as a financial responsibility violation is not proof that cleanup funds were ultimately unavailable. They are failures to satisfy safeguards that regulators require before an emergency or release forces the question.
The evidence trailWhat EPA inspected and what it cited
An EPA representative conducted a compliance evaluation inspection on September 17, 2024. The agency said the violations were identified from that inspection and additional information later provided by Montgomery Petro.
| Requirement | Period identified | Authority cited | What the order does not specify |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual testing of automatic line leak detectors | At least April 20 to September 11, 2024 | 40 C.F.R. Β§ 280.44(a) and COMAR 26.10.05.05(B) | Which tank or detector was involved, test results, or whether any fuel release occurred |
| Financial responsibility compliance | At least December 15, 2023 to September 15, 2024 | 40 C.F.R. Β§ 280.93 and COMAR 26.10.11.01 | The missing instrument, documentation, amount, or reason for noncompliance |
The agreement uses both βallegesβ and βfindsβ
EPA’s signed settlement states that Montgomery Petro failed to comply with the cited federal and Maryland requirements. The final order ratified the agreement and ordered compliance with its terms.
No admission of the specific facts
Montgomery Petro admitted the jurisdictional allegations, accepted the settlement, waived a hearing and appeal, and certified correction. It did not admit the specific factual allegations.
The physical systemThree tanks installed around October 2021
EPA recorded the following underground storage tanks at the facility. The order does not assign the leak-detector testing violation to a particular tank, so the inventory should not be read as proof that every tank had an untested detector.
| Tank | Capacity | Fuel | Installation stated in order |
|---|---|---|---|
| T6 | 15,000 gallons | Regular-grade gasoline | In or about October 2021 |
| T7A | 9,000 gallons | Premium-grade gasoline | In or about October 2021 |
| T7B | 6,000 gallons | Diesel | In or about October 2021 |
The document identifies Montgomery Petro as the respondent and alleged owner or operator. Although the station is named Colonial Shell, the order does not identify Shell plc or another Shell corporate entity as a respondent or operator.
ChronologyThe compliance gaps preceded the inspection
- EPA’s financial responsibility violation period begins no later than this date.
- EPA’s automatic line leak-detector testing violation period begins no later than this date.
- The cited leak-detector testing period ends.
- The cited financial responsibility period ends.
- An EPA representative conducts the compliance evaluation inspection.
- The regional judicial officer signs the final order, which is filed the same day.
The sequence alone does not establish when each problem was discovered or corrected. EPA said its conclusions were based on both the inspection and information Montgomery Petro supplied afterward.
The settlementCorrection certified, facts not admitted
Montgomery Petro agreed to pay $4,446 within 30 days of the agreement’s effective date. EPA said it considered the statutory penalty factors in Section 9006(c) of the Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, but the document does not show how those factors produced the final figure.
βneither admits nor denies the specific factual allegationsβ Montgomery Petro’s position recorded in the settlement agreement
The company nevertheless accepted several binding terms. It waived its right to a hearing and appeal, agreed not to challenge EPA’s jurisdiction, and certified, subject to civil and criminal penalties for a false submission, that the alleged violations had been corrected and that information supplied to EPA was accurate.
The final order ratified the agreement and directed Montgomery Petro to comply with it. The settlement resolves EPA’s civil penalty claims for the violations described in the agreement. It does not function as an admission of those specific factual allegations.
What is known about harmThe record identifies regulatory risk, not a documented release
Underground fuel-tank rules are preventive. Detector tests concern equipment intended to identify line leaks, while financial responsibility requirements address the operator’s ability to meet covered obligations if a release creates costs or claims.
But this final order does not report a fuel release, failed detector performance, soil or groundwater contamination, cleanup, property damage, health effects, or losses to consumers. It also does not say that the missed requirements caused any environmental harm.
The documented consequence is narrower: EPA brought an administrative enforcement action, obtained a correction certification, and imposed a civil penalty. Any claim about contamination or direct harm to nearby residents would go beyond this record.
What remains unansweredThe final order closes the penalty claim, not every factual gap
The supplied record does not disclose:
- Which automatic line leak detector or tanks were involved in the testing violation.
- Whether testing was late, absent, undocumented, or deficient in another way.
- What caused the financial responsibility violation or what proof was missing.
- The exact dates and methods used to correct either alleged violation.
- Whether environmental sampling or release testing was conducted.
- Whether the $4,446 penalty has been paid.
EPA also reserved its authority to act in response to any condition it determines may present an imminent and substantial endangerment to public health, public welfare, or the environment. That reservation is standard enforcement language in the agreement. It is not a finding that such an endangerment existed at Colonial Shell.
The order answers the narrow enforcement question: Montgomery Petro accepted a $4,446 penalty and certified correction. It does not answer the environmental question readers may care about most, whether anything escaped while the requirements were out of compliance. The record provides no release assessment, sampling result, or cleanup account.
Explore by category
Antitrust
Monopolies and anti-competition tactics used to crush rivals.
View Cases →Product Safety Violations
When companies sell dangerous goods, consumers pay the price.
View Cases →Environmental Violations
Pollution, ecological collapse, and unchecked greed.
View Cases →Labor Exploitation
Wage theft, worker abuse, and unsafe conditions.
View Cases →Data Breaches & Privacy
Misuse and mishandling of personal information.
View Cases →Financial Fraud & Corruption
Lies, scams, and executive impunity that distort markets.
View Cases →Intellectual Property
IP theft that punishes originality and rewards copying.
View Cases →Misleading Marketing
False claims that waste money and bury critical safety info.
View Cases →


